Lost and Gone For A While
February 09, 2010, 11:56:09 AM *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
News: Welcome! If you've stumbled in here by accident, you should check out Lost and Gone Forever to see why these forums exist.
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register  
Pages: [1] 2 3
  Print  
Author Topic: Official "One of Us" Instant Reactions Comments Area!  (Read 2587 times)
brian
Lost... and Gone Forever
Administrator
Dharma
*****
Posts: 264



« on: April 12, 2007, 03:21:40 AM »

You made it! Let's see how this crazy experiment works. Comment away!
Logged
Eric
Guest
« Reply #1 on: April 12, 2007, 03:33:29 AM »

Just as we found out through a plot twist right at the end that Juliet was pulling the wool over our losties' eyes, I have high hopes that it will turn out that Jack knew not to trust Juliet and is setting her up (by gaining her trust) to see what she is really up to.  I just hate to think that he gets fooled every time!  It would be nice if he remembers that Ben told him that Juliet is "One of us [the Others]," and sets her up this time ...
Logged
atc154
Guest
« Reply #2 on: April 12, 2007, 03:39:02 AM »

So are we know sure the others did not know flight 815 was coming or cuase it to crash because who was on it?? -- Due to the scene with patchy and all
Logged
the Other Brian
Other
***
Posts: 175



« Reply #3 on: April 12, 2007, 03:44:46 AM »

Great Instant Reaction, Brian--this was indeed an excellent episode.  Mikhail/The Others certainly had a pretty wide net to know that Sawyer killed that guy--or does "Jacob" just give them all the info?  I thought that Smokey was pretty dangerously removed from science, but Jacob has Smokey topped.  He can cure cancer, huh?  (At least *off* the Island.)  This is beginning to sound a bit like Rambaldi from Alias...which I don't think is a good thing.  But, just as Jack trusts Juliet, I trust the producers... Roll Eyes


Brian, have a great trip, and welcome to the Others filing in!


Brian L.
Logged
the Other Brian
Other
***
Posts: 175



« Reply #4 on: April 12, 2007, 03:45:55 AM »

(oops...that was supposed to be "filling in"!)
Logged
Christie
Guest
« Reply #5 on: April 12, 2007, 04:15:53 AM »

Have a great trip Brian, it's really a wonderful thing to experience different cultures, hope you have a blast!  We'll miss you, but hopefully not too much, the blog goes on.  Happy travels, dude.
Logged
Christie
Guest
« Reply #6 on: April 12, 2007, 04:27:28 AM »

Ok, sorry I have to post twice, but I forgot to ask, why did they show Locke on next week preview, when I was under the impression we weren't supposed to see him until May. Or is it, we see a little of him next week, and don't get a flashback till May?
Logged
GeZuS
Crash Landed
*
Posts: 10



WWW
« Reply #7 on: April 12, 2007, 04:33:27 AM »


Jack was right. She will do ANYTHING to get off the island.

Maybe one week means she is supposed to report back her findings/information. 

Implant in Clarie? WTF?!?

They can cure cancer? Why are they so greedy and not share this information with the outside world?

How do we know if Rachel really got cancer again? Seems like a lie to keep Juliet on the island longer, and the only reason they let her see a video of Rachel was used as a barging chip if she every completely broke down.


Logged
Matt
Guest
« Reply #8 on: April 12, 2007, 05:19:01 AM »

Do the other's have a crapload of cameras implanted on various people? It seemed odd to me that they had a live feed of Juliet's sister happily playing with "Julian". I know they can access the outside world, but Brian is right, in that this Jacob dude is ridiculously all-knowing. How else would they have known about "James" and his fowl deeds, unless they had someone with a camera working overtime. GREAT episode. I'll miss you, brian, and I hardly know thee...Hurry back, and don't get lost.
Logged
gaughan
Crash Landed
*
Posts: 2


« Reply #9 on: April 12, 2007, 06:14:46 AM »

For the camera thing....I think it was Alpert manning the camera, it wasn't just some random camera they had.
Where are these people getting their cash?Huh
I have EXTREMELY high hopes for the last 5 episodes.
I am liking the new message board, very classy.

Look at that, I used an emoticon and didn't even try to.
Logged
Salvar
Guest
« Reply #10 on: April 12, 2007, 07:02:46 AM »

You know what the first thing was that passed through my mind when they showed Juliet the video? It's prerecorded. The whole thing looked so planned, so coordinated. Yes, they had today's newspaper to prove the date--but why would they need to prove the date? Those are the actions of one who is hiding something--offering up proof before it's asked for. And we know that there's something funky they can do with time. Ben went there with a purpose, knowing that now was the time he needed Juliet to be one of "us".
(That's what the scene and his behavior said to me, of course... but if it was prerecorded, even supposing they could get a newspaper with any date on it, how would they know to get that specific date? Doesn't quite add up, unfortunately. I'm still suspicious, though.)

And I have to say that I would have enjoyed the ending a lot more if they had succeeded in convincing me that Juliet was on the level. Unfortunately, it wasn't as big of a shock because they made it ambiguous, or even less so--she had that "Henry Gale" smile on the entire time, and she totally played Sayid and Sawyer (and they knew it, too). Not that it was bad, though. It even verified that Juliet was the one Kate saw, with the blue shirt.

One more thing: implant in Claire? They must have been planning this for a long time. If Juliet was lying, then what exactly did they want with Claire? I'm really surprised that they're not more fascinated with her--she gave birth successfully on the island!
Okay, two more things. What else might have been in that case--hidden underneath the padding, maybe--hmm? And what was that symbol by the tree. It looked a bit familiar--although I might just be thinking of the numbers in Riven, which look slightly similar but are definitely different.
That reminds me, another thing reminded me of Myst--the last scene of the submarine from above, as they're walking away. Change that into a spaceship, and you're on Myst island!
Woo, what a twist that would be. Cheesy
Logged
Stef
Guest
« Reply #11 on: April 12, 2007, 11:27:06 AM »

My initial thought was know all about the survivors cuz after the plane went down, they watched the news coverage and researched the list of passengers that way. They have a very deep level of information on everyone, so it's probably more than just what was in news stories or basic Google searches -- might the Others subscribe to Lexis-Nexis???;-) - but the other commenters who keep mentioning Sawyer killing the guy the night before are right. Unless the news was covering this - as in "one of the missing 815 passengers is now wanted for murder in Australia. Film at 11." - and the police had figured it out to track down James Ford, then the Others do have a much more sophisticated level of knowledge about our survivors.

Is Jacob all knowing? Not sure - I'm still leaning towards the Ben as the Wizard theory, and that there is no Jacob. But I can't wait to learn more!

The message board is a great idea, btw. More and more hours of LOST fun!
Logged
Alec
Administrator
Four-Toed Wonder
*****
Posts: 624



WWW
« Reply #12 on: April 12, 2007, 12:33:46 PM »


How do we know if Rachel really got cancer again? Seems like a lie to keep Juliet on the island longer, and the only reason they let her see a video of Rachel was used as a barging chip if she every completely broke down.


That was exactly what I was thinking while I was watching. When Ben said "I'm not a liar," it made my skin crawl. Ben is an incredible liar, when he needs to be. E.g., the whole Henry Gale thing. The idea of the Others being able to cure cancer off of the island struck me as pretty far-fetched. Maybe if they brought Rachel to the island, the island could cure her, but I'm pretty sure that wasn't in the cards.

Although, Brian's blog post got me thinking... Maybe the whole "wish" thing is real. If they can magically conjure Locke's dad, that potentially shows some big off-island pull. So maybe they can cure cancer off the island, too. But something about this all rings kind of strange to me -- like it'd take some of the whole Lost-is-about-science theme and tap dance all over it.
Logged
robin
Crash Landed
*
Posts: 1



« Reply #13 on: April 12, 2007, 01:00:29 PM »

I posted this in the other comment section, but I figured I'd throw it out over here, too... Wink
Just a small thought...But when Juliet told Jack "I AM alone (or on my own?)," I think she meant it...So that even though she's spying for Ben and Co. (which will inevitably separate her from the Losties, she's still just doing what she has to in order to get herself off the island. Not really an other...but not really a Lostie...
Logged
Drudo
Survivor
**
Posts: 73



« Reply #14 on: April 12, 2007, 01:20:58 PM »

Ok, sorry I have to post twice, but I forgot to ask, why did they show Locke on next week preview, when I was under the impression we weren't supposed to see him until May. Or is it, we see a little of him next week, and don't get a flashback till May?

Christie, the preview they showed last night was for the next 5 weeks.  There were scenes from all of those.  Great post Brian!  I agree this may be the best episode I've seen.  Maybe I'm gullible, but I had completely fallen for Juliet as a repentant convert.  I was completely shocked by the last scene.  I agree with others though about Jack.  He is normally so slow to trust.  Maybe being hurt by Kate made him too quick to want to believe Juliet.

The demonstration of off-island influence wasn't really shocking.  I'm curious to see how the writer's explain it.  Magical wish granting doesn't seem to fit into the pseudo-science the writer's have promised, but then how else could the Other's coordinate a man to get hit by a bus that quickly.  WHO IS JACOB?!?!?

That's all for me.
Logged
Pages: [1] 2 3
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.4 | SMF © 2006-2007, Simple Machines LLC Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!